Originally Posted by
Linda_D
I have been in favor of this project from the beginning because these guys are putting their own money up front. You are the one who's been knocking their plans from Day 1.
I am for the project as well. I just feel that the two guys behind the current plans do not have the money or skill to complete the project. I feel they are doing what they can, buy the land, develop plans and get approval, but will wait until they find backing to start. I hope they prove me wrong. But I doubt it.
You've made a lot of excuses as to why you don't think this project will go, lefty, but then you turn around and paint this picture of thousands of condos on the NFTA land to the north. I think what you're really afraid of is that this project will be successful and prove that removing the Skyway and the elevated section of Fuhrman Blvd is NOT AND NEVER HAS BEEN a detriment to development on the Outer Harbor.
Why this project will not go under these two guys is different from what I think should go out there and why. I feel that an experienced developer with the money to do the project would favor the boulevard and not the DOT combo. Until these guys pony up the millions needed to start and COMPLETE the project, I will continue to think this way.
In some ways this project is perfect to settle the matter once and for all. If these guys are able to secure financing AND FIND BUYERS for this project AND FIND A HOTEL to operate out there with the DOT plan, I will be 100% wrong. So you are right. If this project goes off, then I would be wrong.
So, I guess we should wait until the secure financing, prove there is interest in the condos and find a hotel that is willing to invest out there.
BTW, my opposition to Outer Harbor development has always been to putting public money into creating a large-scale project that has as its aim to "revitalize Buffalo". I have no problem with private developers risking their own funds on projects they think are worthy.
I can see why you would think this and I think you know from my other comments I love private investment as well. This is my problem with the DOT/Higgins plan. They have NEVER factored in what was going to be the best option to allow for private investment.
It is moronic to think that private investment should cover State roads. The issue is should the state spend $50million on what some feel as a patch or spend $150-$200million on developing what is proven to encourage private development.
The side that you never recognise is IF the current DOT plan is done and it does prevent development like MANY people think, the state will have wasted $50million on the "patch" and keep the city committed to maintaining the skyway AND prevent development. A total loss!
What then Linda? Fast forward 15 years. The DOT pushed through the combo and it was completed in 2011. The combo hurts development and the only thing that goes out there are parks and green space. Saying I told you so, although it would be sweet, would not fix the problem.
How do you propose to fix the situation if people like me are right in 15 years?
By "public money", I include $$$ spent removing the Skyway and building the so-called Southtowns Connector to appease the sensibilities of "urbanists" and their brainwashed followers as well as other expensive stupid crap like a covered football stadium and/or convention center. I don't care how Brian Higgins, the ex-mayor of Minneapolis, you, keyboard, and the folks at BuffaloRising slice, dice, and spin it, the fact is that a few thousand people living out on the Outer Harbor will never "turn the city around".
You are correct that none of these project will turn the city around. However, IF all of the projects are done AND other things like responsible government and productive improvement in public services and the schools are folded in Buffalo can turn around.
This comment is so telling of you. You have very little hope or desire for the COB to ever turn things around. You moved to Jamestown because of it and have vowed to NEVER move back.
The way I read you is you want the city to give up or simply not try because you have a preconceived notion that the city will fail. You just want to ride out the rest of your days and have it cost as little as possible. Even if this mindset kills any chance for the future of Buffalo when you are long and gone.
As for the climate on the Outer Harbor, I will stick by my stand that it's not conducive to foot traffic for much of the year. The next time you fly in from South Cali for Christmas, you take some time to do some jogging along the newly installed bikepath -- if you can find it under the snow.