That's odd you would have any kid from another town on your league if it's a town league. I would have assumed you would have to live in the town you were going to play hockey for.
Does anyone think the town needs to force the youth hockey association in West Seneca known as the West Seneca Wings to adapt residency rule for our youth hockey teams? Currently, the association has no residency rule and allows kids from all over WNY to represent West Seneca while kids from West Seneca transplanted all over.
With West Seneca East & West joining the premier federation league in WNY – I think we need to have a proper feeder for our varsity teams to ensure success for those teams.
Amherst, Hamburg, Cheektowaga has residency rules
Amherst Rule
a player must reside in the Town and/or attend one of the Williamsville schools, Amherst, or Sweet Home. At minor P.W. and up, at the AAA (Tier One) level, each team may have FOUR non-residents. If a non-resident is selected as a HEAD Coach of a AAA team or is an Instructor ( ie; Dave Smith or James Patrick) then his child may play at any level of AAA or the Girl's program. There is no preference given to an Amherst player. In other words, if a non-resident is slightly better than an Amherst resident, then the coach is encouraged to pick the non-resident.
Cheektowaga
85% of the teams must be from the Town of Cheektowaga
I would propose the town force the youth hockey association to adapt similar rules. How can I contact the town board members via email or postal?
Also, anyone feel the rink is a money loser? What about naming rights for the rink?
That's odd you would have any kid from another town on your league if it's a town league. I would have assumed you would have to live in the town you were going to play hockey for.
Buffalo Web Hosting and Graphic Design
www.onlinemedia.net - www.vinyl-graphics.com
Web hosting / Web Design - Signs, Banners, Vehicle Graphics
I'm afraid not. I know someone who lives in Tonawanda, and his kid played here. Who knows, maybe the price of gas will cause a residency rule.Originally Posted by WNYresident
I'd rather be hated for who I am... than loved for who I'm not!
So these are basically sport leagues if they allow anyone to play.Originally Posted by Psycho1
How much do these leagues cost the tax payer?
I would expect the "cheektowaga" team to be 100% cheektowaga kids playing against 100% kids from another town.
Buffalo Web Hosting and Graphic Design
www.onlinemedia.net - www.vinyl-graphics.com
Web hosting / Web Design - Signs, Banners, Vehicle Graphics
"Travel" is the competitive where they travel all over WNY and sometimes the state and country.Originally Posted by WNYresident
"House" is the less competitive where there is a residency rule, teams are drafted and play teams entirely within WS Youth Hockey at WS Ice Rink and Leisure.
AAA - Most proficient level of play
AA - Next level of proficiency
A - Next level of proficiency
House - Lowest Level
West Seneca's House program has a residency rule of 1st town residents 2nd school district 3rd non-residents
On some WS Travel teams (name's by birth years) have less than 6 residents on a team and coached by non-residents. Residents not given the priority over non-residents. It's a shame that our town teams that travel all over the country are represented by kids from Buffalo, Kenmore, Lewiston, Niagara Falls, Williamsville, Orchard Park, Elma, etc. In the past, teams have had 0 kids on the team.
What's the purpose of the name West Seneca? Why are residents from WS forced to play somewhere else because kids from the above mentioned towns want to play here. We allow them to use West Seneca as a banner name and without a true representation of the town of West Seneca.
Did I mention, we force House teams to play at Leisure because the ice is given to Travel teams. So much for house teams filled with West Seneca kids to use their own town rink!
I played A and AA for Amherst in the 70's and 80's and I remember some parents who didnt like the coach, so they bought land in Wheatfield so their kids could play for the wheatfield team. That team consistantly won State and went on to win Nationals. Some of those very kids made it to AAA and the Pro's. We were the only team in Amherst to always get Second place and always to Wheatfield.
I remember never having a problem beating West Seneca by half a dozen goals or more.
Perhaps West Seneca NEEDS to be able to recruit players from out of town to be competetive? The kids who tryout and dont make the good teams will still have a chance at playing in a league at their appropriate skill level.
I emailed both of the female board members and got no response. Two days and no reply?
I'm somewhat confused here, are you stating you have a child who has nowhere to play on any hockey team in town because too many non-residents are playing in the town leagues ? I only ask for clarification because I know an awful lot of town residents who have children of all ages from 4 yrs. old and up playing in town leagues. It seems like their at a rink all the time. I will be seeing some this weekend, I will have to ask them about this situation you speak of.
Fee for non-residents = problem solved.
I re-read your posts and the others in this thread. I have to ask you, could it be your child didn't make one of the premier -AAA OR AA teams ? Is that it ? I'm getting the impression your child does play in town on a hockey team, but it is not in stature of what you desire or deem suitable for him. I've heard about these premier teams with boys baseball and girls softball teams in town. It's my opinion with many of these types of teams it's often more about the parents bragging rights than what is best for the kid. Did you check to see if these other premier town sports team programs are for town residents only. I hope you did before deriding how things are in one town youth sports program.
Additionally, though you've given a couple of board members "two whole days" to get back to you on this very pressing town issue you desperately need addressed, I believe Mrs. Bove and Mrs. Meegan have more important matters at hand regarding the town than one kids parent(s) who aren't happy about their kid playing hockey on what they percieve as an inferior hockey team.
Is that the case ? Non Residents pay more ? If so, great point Socko.
You obviously have no idea how travel hockey is run, a residency rule for all the hockey organizations will never happen, I live in Hamburg, my kids play for West Seneca travel hockey, they have also played for the regals, Depew and Hamburg. House league may have residency rules, I'm not familiar, but with travel you have to tryout, kids from all over WNY come to tryouts, the best 15 or so are picked no matter where they live, and as a non resident I pay a non resident fee above the 1300-1400 fee to be on the team. I think there was 3 kids the most who actually lived in WS on my sons team last year, its a different level of play, you cant just play on a team because you live down the street from the rink, unless its a house league team, thats just how it is.
Hamburg travel hockey does not have a residency rule.
If you're talking to me .......guilty as charged.Originally Posted by snapple
I did get a reply and the matter is being handled by Mrs. Meegan and Mrs. Bove. I guess 3 days is the keyOriginally Posted by Spirit of Ebenezer
Amherst is more successful than West Seneca. Why can't West Seneca adapt a similar policy? AA teams must be all residents and AAA teams can have four non-residents.Originally Posted by snapple
My one son plays at WS and other was forced to play on another team because of a team filled with non-residents. That's the problem.
do your kids play house or travel?Originally Posted by wnyfuture
travelOriginally Posted by snapple
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)